Invest in Land or a Small 3-unit Apartment? Details inside
My cousin in Mexico is looking to either buy a small apartment, or invest in land (to build on in 5 years). She asked me for my advice, but I thought it would be best to to post this question to the community to get your opinion. Which would you choose? (all amounts below in USD).
A) The Apartment ($75,000 + $15,000 in renovations. 1,300sq ft)
-3 loft units (1 br / 1 bath each) + a commercial storefront
-Each loft can be rented out for an average of $300 a month (she mentions there wouldn't be much tax to pay on this income).
-The storefront she can rent out for $150 a month (she mentions there wouldn't be much tax to pay on this income)
-She will pay a $10,000 down payment
-Loan from the bank (for $65 of the $75k) is at a 8% interest rate, 20 year mortgage.
-located close to city center. it's an ok part of town. ~15min walk to the historic center but also it is 10-15min from a poorer rundown area
B) The Land ($40,000 total price / 3,229 total sq ft ÷ 2 = 1,615sq ft for her)
-Will split the the land with a close friend, 50/50
-Of the $20,000 she's responsible for, she will pay out of pocket $7,500. Dad will loan her $2,500
-For the remaining $10,000, she will get a loan from the bank (to pay for the amount she can't pay in cash): 36 months to pay, 22% is the apr. She can pay this off early in 18 months.
-This is in a very good area. A lot of projected growth over next 10-20 years, high income area, across the street from a new private school (k-12)
-Withinn 5 years she would like to build a house (to live or rent out), or 2-3 apartments on the space. This project would be between $50,000 - $75,000. The bank will loan her 70% of the total project price, at 10%.
Interesting thread. Wish I could rent a loft for 300.
As a landlord or tenant?
Tenant.
lol I thought you guys would get a kick out of the prices, 75k for 1300 sq feet?! not bad
To really answer the question you would need additional info. What condition is the Option A building in? Is the $15K renovation cost accurate, and will there be expensive ongoing capex? How would she manage the building? What are local vacancy rates and cap rates like? Etc.
That said, it seems like the Option A building would generate positive cashflow, so that appears to be a better bet on paper. Not sure why she'd buy land that she intends to leave vacant for a few years- committing herself to interest payments, property taxes, and tied up equity that's not generating a return. It's basically speculation on land appreciation. If she wants to build something in 5 years, she would be better off investing her money in an index fund until she's ready to build. Unless she's getting an amazing below-market deal on the land.
Thanks for the reply.
Since I posted that, the bank offered her a pretty good deal on a loan to build (between 8-11%, same as the apartment), so she plans to build in the next year.
The price of the land is a pretty good deal, owner is strapped for cash and selling for below market value.
She's going through the buying process now and hopes to finalize on the land soon.
$1050/month with $65K at 8%, completely ignoring the rehab here, $544/month mortgage net of property taxes and insurance. Leaves her with $494 to pay all expenses, interest and principal on rehab loan, and taxes. Depends on what that number is. Plus the risk factor. Seems pretty weak to me.
There are places in the USA where you can get rent like that per unit on a basis of 40 - 50K for a duplex.
Quia dolor sit recusandae dolores. Eum dignissimos velit amet. Quo suscipit dolor sunt qui molestiae quia tempora. Minus cupiditate ipsa et ut omnis soluta deserunt accusamus.
Ipsam labore totam molestiae magni illum neque. Sint ratione voluptas molestias voluptas. A vero maiores autem autem quis. Architecto consequuntur et laudantium sapiente minus repudiandae. Libero laboriosam et ipsa nam sit nisi qui. Ea possimus praesentium iste ex placeat. Sint perspiciatis deleniti sint perspiciatis est quo qui.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...